drremedy: This is an edit of one of my work, I didn't give permission to anyone to edit my works. I would like this to be deleted. Various versions of it is planned but you guys really can't wait for an official one, can you? I would've appreciated if you asked for my permission first.
jubilation_t_cornpone: Sorry, but permission is not required for edits. Use of the "edit" tag is required, so the original artist is not blamed for any flaws in the edit, but that was done in this case.
And for that matter, anyone, including you, can add the tag after the fact.
It goes without saying that removal of the edit tag by you would be tag vandalism, one of our most serious rule violations.
drremedy: I never thought of removing the `edit` tag, and do I really have to file a DMCA takedown for my rights to be respected? I didn't give any consent to anyone to modify my works and yet lo and behold someone disregarded everything I said, "Do not repost, trace, or edit my art!"
jubilation_t_cornpone: Take it up with the person who did the edit, as that is who disregarded what you said. He has not broken any rules on our site, so we will take no action against him.
Farfegnugen: @drremedy: They don't have to get your consent anyway. It's a "professional courtesy" to let you know they are doing an edit, but there's no reason they have to.
A DMCA takedown for an edit? I'm sure Disney, Blizzard, Marvel, and Nintendo would love to do that for 99.9% of the Rule 34 porn out there. Darn that pesky First Amendment right.
Anonymous1: Wow seriously? You guys are ok with art theft when the original artist themselves doesn't want you editing their art? The hell is wrong with you all?
Anonymous2(1): I get that all of the stuff on here is owned by someone or some company, but when an artist big or small doesn't want their stuff copied or edited without their permission then it shouldn't be copied or edited. Plain and simple. Drremedy if you're seeing this I'm sorry that the people here are behaving like entitled children, I sincerely hope you don't stop drawing because of these children.
Jankerdoodle: "5. If you are an artist or a copyright holder of images on this site and don’t wish them to be here, then email the moderator team at staff@paheal.net. Don't go ranting in the comments section; be mature about it and contact us directly. Details here."
Farfegnugen: @Anonymous Bring this public? Telling an artist they can't control what's uploaded to the site? I'm sure the only "people got pissed" is one artist because they choose to upload something not porn while someone made it porn. Oh, the scandal...
Anonymous4: @Farfegnugen: um did you not read that the person was GOING to make the edit? the issue wasnt the edit it was the artist who posted it someone made an edit before the artist could cuz people are impatient and when asked to take it down so the artist could the admin decided to be "throw the book" at the wrong person.
Anonymous5: @Farfegnugen: The artist cared. That's why. Some of you jackoffs acted all entitled and now they won't make art anymore. All because some people thought editing their art when they didn't want that was ok. In other words don't go shitting in someone's pot when they say you can't use it.
Anonymous6: @Anonymous: the editor is not even that good. I looked at the images he edits and needed to bleach my eyes. I get there isn’t quality control on this site but come on the ones that are not even trying at least need some pants kicking.
Anonymous7: Why tf is there a heated argument on a porn site??? I thought youtube comments were the toxic ones and porn comments were the more chill bunches lol
- Reply
And for that matter, anyone, including you, can add the tag after the fact.
It goes without saying that removal of the edit tag by you would be tag vandalism, one of our most serious rule violations.
- Reply
- Reply
A DMCA takedown for an edit? I'm sure Disney, Blizzard, Marvel, and Nintendo would love to do that for 99.9% of the Rule 34 porn out there. Darn that pesky First Amendment right.
- Reply
- Reply
- Reply