Anonymous7: @Anonymous: She wasn't going to suck your dick anyway, trans or not. Won't stop you from wanking to her cisfem smut anyway so why does it matter
Anonymous8: She "canonically" is not. The devs have been silent on the issue, for fans to come to their own conclusions. The flag is there in ch 9, and that's all. Maybe she is, maybe not. Who knows.
Anonymous9: I think the devs are silent on it just so it doesnt blow up and enter the wrong circles, and also possibly because it is later in the game that you see the flag so it would be a bit of a spoiler. It does go well with the games themes of anxiety and self worth for Madeline to be trans, but its not the main point they wanted to make. It makes sense that they wouldnt want it to be a main focus too, given trans people dont really want everyone around them knowing that they're trans. The reality is that Madeline is a person, trans or not, and so she shouldnt be judged by whats in her pants
Now because this is a hentai comment section that I've written this in, I am obliged to tell you to go jack off to something else if you dont like girls with dicks.
Anonymous12(11): @ChronoWarp: She literally cannonically isn't
-There's no official statement saying she is
-The flags in her room are a nod to trans rights activism (the devs are very pro trans rights), they do not mean she inmediately is trans
-The picture of her with short hair proves nothing, not only is short hair femenine too but there's also another official artwork that features her still in a very young age with long hair
-The pills are regular anxiety/antidepressants pills
-There's never in the game any possible nod to her being transgender aside from those 3 previously mentioned factors which only came in the DLC
It's ok if you want to relate to her by being trans, but dont go around preaching and acting like it's a 100% cannonical thing
Anonymous15: Yeah why the hell are y'all acting like you exposed the well known truth or something, there literally wasn't any official statement by the time the comments were made.
It's like if I complained about a newspaper from 12 years ago not being accurate for the current day lmao
Anonymous16: @Anonymous: I'm sorry for needing more substantial evidence for such an important part of a characters life? Did you just expect me to have my games' inclusion be there as a fucking easter egg? I'm glad they confirmed it, they had to. Nothing less.
Anonymous18: I think it’s quite fucking stupid that everyone’s arguing on here about Madeline’s gender identity. Some have indeed made good points in the past before the confirmation that you don’t have to be trans to be an activist, could’ve been anti-depressant pills or that she was a non-trans girl who just had really short hair in the past. Calling others stupid before the confirmation was even announced during the debate is fucking dumb.
Small hints aren’t always full on evidence unless devs say otherwise. It’s like with Rivet from Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart that people argued and forced people to believe that she’s trans because of the 1 single detail that she had a tail for a Female Lombax. But for all they know that information about female Lombaxes lacking tails could’ve been outdated since we’ve only seen 1 female Lombax (Angela Cross) a long time ago throughout the whole franchise and she was literally only shown back in 2002. She’s not even fully confirmed as a Lombax yet but people think otherwise because of her colour scheme of her fur being just like Ratchet’s.
What I’m trying to say is don’t get hostile towards others who have a different opinion from you if they’re not doing the same to you. 2 wrongs do not make a right. Ignore the people who don’t share your opinion. You don’t have to like it, but you do have to accept that they won’t always be your view and respect them. No one here’s announcing hate speech towards Trans people (Except for Anon21. They should just, you know, seek help from that statement.)
Anonymous19: You can't retroactively make something cannon imo, if you write a story with a character in mind, that's who that character is, you can't just change it later. I feel this way about this game, Harry Potter, and black butler(I consider the whole 2nd season to be non-canonical)
Anonymous23: @Anonymous: It's a tranny character from a liberal indie game, don't be too confused. Go jerk off to some proper cock and ignore this degeneracy.
Anonymous24: (i'm referring to the comments made before the devs revealed it) just because madeleine wasn't confirmed trans at the time doesn't mean it's wrong or forced to draw her as trans.
Now because this is a hentai comment section that I've written this in, I am obliged to tell you to go jack off to something else if you dont like girls with dicks.
Shut up retard
-There's no official statement saying she is
-The flags in her room are a nod to trans rights activism (the devs are very pro trans rights), they do not mean she inmediately is trans
-The picture of her with short hair proves nothing, not only is short hair femenine too but there's also another official artwork that features her still in a very young age with long hair
-The pills are regular anxiety/antidepressants pills
-There's never in the game any possible nod to her being transgender aside from those 3 previously mentioned factors which only came in the DLC
It's ok if you want to relate to her by being trans, but dont go around preaching and acting like it's a 100% cannonical thing
- Reply
https://twitter.com/MaddyThorson/status/1324579049256136704?s=20
https://maddythorson.medium.com/is-madeline-canonically-trans-4277ece02e40
- Reply
It's like if I complained about a newspaper from 12 years ago not being accurate for the current day lmao
Small hints aren’t always full on evidence unless devs say otherwise. It’s like with Rivet from Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart that people argued and forced people to believe that she’s trans because of the 1 single detail that she had a tail for a Female Lombax. But for all they know that information about female Lombaxes lacking tails could’ve been outdated since we’ve only seen 1 female Lombax (Angela Cross) a long time ago throughout the whole franchise and she was literally only shown back in 2002. She’s not even fully confirmed as a Lombax yet but people think otherwise because of her colour scheme of her fur being just like Ratchet’s.
What I’m trying to say is don’t get hostile towards others who have a different opinion from you if they’re not doing the same to you. 2 wrongs do not make a right. Ignore the people who don’t share your opinion. You don’t have to like it, but you do have to accept that they won’t always be your view and respect them. No one here’s announcing hate speech towards Trans people (Except for Anon21. They should just, you know, seek help from that statement.)